@BODYAGEBUSTER Fitness After 50, Living Longer Better
  • Home
  • Test Yourself
  • Speaking
  • About
  • Blog
  • Fitness After 50 Free eBook

 Blog

SEARCH My Blog (Opens in new tab)

Overweight and Over 65, You Might Live Longer Than Someone At Their Best BMI

2/5/2020

Comments

 
Picture
Image credit: Screenshot | The Author

How to stop trending towards “skinny-fat” as you age

Calculating your body mass index (BMI) is one way of trying to work out whether you are within a healthy weight range for your height. However, recent research found that a "healthy" BMI was not associated with the longest life - if you are over 65.

That's a surprising finding, despite the well-known limitations of the BMI as a predictor of good health. Let's examine some of those limitations and then review the implications of the research for over 65s.
You can calculate your BMI here.

BMI has a fundamental flaw

The limitations of BMI are manyfold, but they come down to one fundamental "flaw", which is this: BMI is a surrogate measure of body fatness.

This means that BMI does not measure body fatness directly but rather, as a proxy measure of body fat. It is directly a measure of excess weight  - rather than excess body fat. 

If the body composition of "excess weight" was consistent and distributed evenly across the population, and that specific composition was associated with consistent health outcomes, then BMI would be a good indicator of those outcomes.

But none of those conditions is true.

For example, the BMI of 100m Olympic Champions has increased consistently over the last 100 years.
Picture
Image credit: Topend Sports - Anthropometric Measurements of 100m Olympic Champions
Since the BMI is used to indicate body fat, does this mean that their body fat has increased?

Clearly not. Modern sprinters no doubt have lower body fat and more muscle than previous generation sprinters. In this case - for this subset of the population - using body weight as a surrogate measure of body fat is highly inaccurate.

Nevertheless, BMI is a useful health indicator and the WHO recommends its use as "the most useful population-level measure of overweight and obesity as it is the same for both sexes and for all ages of adults".

For adults, WHO defines overweight and obesity as follows:
  • overweight is a BMI greater than or equal to 25; and
  • obesity is a BMI greater than or equal to 30.

However, what recent research uncovered is that for an older population those with an "overweight" BMI had a lower "all-cause" mortality than those with a healthy BMI rating. This applied to both men and women.

However, those with a BMI rated as "obesity" did not have lower mortality outcomes than those who were rated "healthy".  So more weight — more than being “overweight” — was not better.

There is an above-average weight-for-height sweet spot which is associated with longer life (for older people).

The researchers postulated that lean body mass, i.e. skeletal muscle, is relatively higher in those in the "overweight" BMI category. This kind of makes sense, as you could think about this hypothesis the other way around.

For people over 65, who are not exercising, as their BMI falls down through the "healthy" range, their ratio of fat to lean muscle is quickly increasing.
DO THESE TWO QUICK EFFECTIVE PULL EXERCISES TO COMPLEMENT YOUR AT-HOME EXERCISE ROUTINE

Up to 50% loss of muscle by 70

Loss of muscle mass (sarcopenia) occurs at about 1% per year after the age of 30 until age 50, and then an accelerated decline (e.g., 12%-15% per decade in strength) after age 50.

That's massive. If your BMI is remaining constant - for example in the "healthy" range - then you are adding the equivalent to your muscle loss in fat as you age.


Let's do some math and see what that looks like if you don't exercise:
  1. Between 30 and 50 you will lose about 20% (even if you do not compound the annual loss);
  2. Between 50 and 70 you will lose another 24% to 30% (even if you do not compound the annual loss).
This means, in total, you will conservatively lose 44% to 50% of your skeletal muscle mass between 30 and 70 if you do not exercise.

But this does not explain why an older person with an "overweight" BMI has a lower all-cause mortality than another with a "healthy" BMI.

The researchers 
did not determine a reason. (Personally, I think it is because the surrogate use of weight as a measure of body fat fails to account for sarcopenia. Therefore BMI is a poor indicator of mortality outcomes for those over 65 who do not exercise. The BMI needs to be calibrated to typical population rates of muscle loss.)

Reaffirms the importance of maintaining muscle

What the research reconfirmed is that "greater lean tissue mass was associated with improved cardiovascular and overall prognosis". In other words, the more muscle that you maintain and build through exercise the more likely you are to live longer better.

Interestingly, they also found that having a low BMI, below "healthy", was linked to poor outcomes, e.g. "an adverse prognosis". Colloquially, this means that being skinny is not as healthy as people perceive (in the sense of being opposite to fat).

No doubt that is because the people in that skinny category - as a population group - have a very low ratio of lean muscle mass to fat due to sarcopenia. That is, they are "skinny fat"  - and possibly have the worst kind of fat - visceral fat.

What this means is that exercise and retaining as much skeletal muscle as possible is one of the simplest ways to improve your prognosis for a longer better life. And if you are exercising, don't worry if your doctor tells you that your BMI is "overweight".

Good luck.
DON’T LET YOUR BALANCE BREAK DOWN AND REDUCE YOUR LIFESPAN - DO THESE EXERCISES
See My Many Posts On Exercises For Over 50s HERE On This Blog
Follow me on Quora for more health and fitness tips.
If you valued this article >> Follow me
​
​Leave a comment >> Share it >> Stay healthy
If you have any questions email me and I will get back to you.

RSS Feed


Latest: get your free customised fitness plan designed uniquely for you.
Let me match you to your personal choice of exercises,
equipment (or none), frequency, duration and your goals.
 ☞ CLICK HERE



Get More Like This To Help You ⭑Live ⭑Longer ⭑Better
Sign Up For My Free Weekly ⭑Newsletter



Not yet convinced? More details - click here
Read previous newsletters - click here



No content on this site, regardless of date, should ever be used as a substitute for direct medical advice from your doctor or another qualified clinician. Disclaimer.

Comments

    Choices

    Since I was diagnosed at 50 with Type 2 diabetes I've been learning how to do bone-building fitness training which lowers my age. You can too. It's your choice. Walter


    Instant Newsletter Subscription
    CLICK HERE


    Categories

    All
    Aging
    Back
    Balance
    Bodyweight Exercises
    Bones
    Brain
    Cancer
    Cardio
    Cardiovascular
    Covid19
    Dental Health
    Diabetes
    Diet
    Energy Systems
    Exercise Plan
    Fitness After 50
    Food Plan
    Functional Training
    Healthy Gut
    HIIT
    Inflammation
    Insulin
    Isometric
    Joints
    Keto
    Kettlebells
    Life
    Men
    Mental Health
    Newsletter
    New Year Resolutions
    Nutrition
    Pain
    Plant Based
    Quotes
    Running
    Sleep
    Stamina
    Strength Training
    Stretching
    Sugar
    Walking
    Women

    Archives

    May 2023
    February 2023
    November 2022
    October 2022
    July 2022
    February 2022
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018

    RSS Feed

    Picture
    View my profile on LinkedIn
    Picture
    My 300 Health And Fitness Answers On Quora
    Picture
    ⭑Medium Top Writer on Food⭑

Home  

About Walter
Blog
Disclaimer
​Privacy

Services

Consulting
Mentoring
Facilitation
Keynote Speaking
Ambassador
Content

Contact

[email protected]
+61 403 345 632
Message Me
Fitness After 50 FREE EBOOK
© COPYRIGHT 2018. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
Photos from jar [o], Alan Light
  • Home
  • Test Yourself
  • Speaking
  • About
  • Blog
  • Fitness After 50 Free eBook